San Francisco's Family Zoning Plan treats the Alamo Square Historic District building by building. When the Board of Supervisors adopted the map ordinance in December 2025, it kept two kinds of property out of the new R-4 height and bulk district: structures designated as landmarks, and structures designated as contributors to an Article 10 historic district. A noncontributing building inside the district does not get that exemption just because of where it sits.
For a buyer comparing Victorians across the city, the building's rating is part of what is for sale, along with the ratings of the lots next door. The listing will rarely mention either.
The ordinance says more than the summary does
The adopted map ordinance is Board File 250700, Ordinance 244-25. The Board passed it on December 9, 2025, and it was enacted on December 12. The key sentence in the ordinance text reads:
"Properties with structures that have been designated as a landmark or a contributor to a historic district pursuant to Article 10 are excluded from the R-4 Height and Bulk District."
The city's Family Zoning Plan FAQ describes the same amendment from Supervisor Mandelman in shorter terms. It says the amendment exempted "all Article 10 local landmarks" and does not mention district contributors. The Planning Department's own summary of committee amendments uses a similar headline. Its Planning Code description, however, defines the excluded lots as those containing a landmark or a contributor to a historic district. For a specific building, the ordinance text is the controlling source.
Why the line follows the building and not the district
The council did consider exempting whole districts. Mission Local reported in October 2025 that Supervisor Connie Chan proposed removing all historic resources from the plan, historic districts included, while the Mandelman proposal covered landmarks. A month later, Mission Local reported that the district-wide proposal was tabled. The landmark exemption passed because the Planning Department's capacity formula already assumed those sites would not be developed.
State housing officials had warned in a September 9 letter that amendments needed to roughly preserve the new capacity the plan created, according to the same report. Exempting buildings that were never going to be counted as new capacity cost the plan nothing. Exempting whole districts would have removed parcels the formula was counting on. That arithmetic is why, in Alamo Square, the exemption follows the building's rating rather than the district map.
What each rating carries
The Alamo Square Historic District took effect July 6, 1984. Planning describes it as generally bounded by Golden Gate Avenue, Divisadero Street, Webster Street and Fell Street. Planning recognizes three building ratings in Article 10 districts: Contributory, Contributory-Altered and Non-Contributory. The table below compares the two ratings this piece turns on.
| Contributing building | Noncontributing building in the district | |
|---|---|---|
| Family Zoning Plan R-4 height and bulk | Excluded by Ordinance 244-25 | No exemption from district membership alone |
| Certificate of Appropriateness for permitted exterior work | Required | Required |
| New construction in the district | Needs a COA | Needs a COA |
| Interior residential work | Generally not regulated by Article 10 | Generally not regulated by Article 10 |
A noncontributing building gets more zoning potential and keeps the same design review. Planning states that every building in an Article 10 district, noncontributors included, needs a COA or an administrative COA for exterior alterations that require a permit, and that approval comes before the building permit. Any added height on a noncontributing lot still has to go through the district's design review.
The ordinance has one more detail. Contributor and landmark parcels came out of the zoning tables, except for a specific reclassification from RTO to RTO-1, which still applies to those parcels. So a contributing building's zoning may not have stayed entirely the same.
Noncontributors are rare here
A Planning Department staff report describes the district's original ratings as mostly contributing, with a few noncontributing structures. It says more than three-quarters of the buildings date from 1870 to 1910. The same report puts the building stock at about half Victorian and one-third Edwardian, typically two to three stories, with some contributing apartment buildings up to six stories. The research behind this piece did not find an exact count of contributors and noncontributors.
That scarcity matters. If most of a block is contributing, the zoning question is limited to a handful of lots. For a buyer, the house next door may matter more than the house being purchased.
Rating also attaches to structures, not to whole lots. A 2011 staff case report on 940 Grove Street identified the residence as contributing. It described the rear school structures on the same lot as non-historic and proposed for demolition and replacement.
The strip between Fillmore and Webster
The same ordinance section adds a geographic rezoning. Properties north of Haight Street, west of Octavia Street, east of Fillmore Street and south of Fulton Street are also rezoned to R-4. On a map, that area appears to overlap the district's eastern edge, the blocks between Fillmore and Webster south of Fulton. The research for this piece did not confirm the overlap parcel by parcel. The ordinance points to its incorporated parcel tables for that. Anyone comparing homes on those blocks should check the actual tables.
What the sale prices don't show
In June, the San Francisco Standard reported that the silver Victorian at 1164 Fulton St. sold for $9.125 million, a price record for Alamo Square. The Standard said the price was about $2 million below asking and that the two-unit building next door had sold in April for $4 million. Citywide, the California Association of Realtors puts San Francisco's August 2026 single-family median at $1,875,000, up 25 percent from August 2025 and down from $2,050,000 in July 2026. Median time on market in August 2026 was 34 days.
Neither number says what a particular lot can become. A record sale or a citywide median prices the house as it stands. The building's rating and the ratings of its neighbors decide what can be built there and next to it later, and those facts are in Planning records, not in the sale history.
Checking a building before you write an offer
- Look up the address in the Property Information Map. You can search by address, parcel or Planning application number. The report includes sections for Historic Evaluation and for Article 10 Districts and Landmarks.
- Read the status code. PIM's glossary defines code 5D1 as a contributor to a locally listed or designated district.
- Confirm with Planning staff. PIM labels its displayed historic status as tentative and refers users to a Preservation Technical Specialist at 628.652.7300 or [email protected]. The district's designation record includes its original 1984 case report, so staff can check a building against that record.
- Run the same lookup on the adjacent lots. If a neighbor's building is noncontributing, that lot did not get the exemption that applies to contributing buildings.
- Map out the exterior work you plan. Article 10 Appendix E requires COAs for street-visible awnings, copings, retaining walls, fences, balustrades and security grates. It also covers specified work on previously unpainted masonry. Paint color is not regulated. Window replacements that need a permit get additional review.
The COA process depends on the size of the project. Major work goes to a public hearing before the Historic Preservation Commission. The commission can delegate smaller scopes to staff for administrative approval. The Planning Department's application form describes a 20-day mailed notice period and site posting. It ties the fee to estimated construction cost, with possible added charges for staff time. The administrative COA form says there is no set fee. It also describes a 20-day window in which commissioners or interested parties can request a hearing. These forms are dated 2020, so current procedures should be confirmed with Planning.
A recent example of a hearing: according to a recap published by Citizen Portal, the commission unanimously approved a COA with conditions for alterations and limited additions at 1060 Fulton Street in May 2025.
What could still change
Two newer developments affect the rules. SF Planning's SB 79 factsheet says the state transit-upzoning law took effect July 1, 2026. It provides temporary parcel exemptions through 2032, including for properties on a local historic register as of January 1, 2025, and it allows a certified city Alternative Plan to replace SB 79's height limits. The factsheet does not say how noncontributing parcels inside an Article 10 district are treated under that exemption.
SF Heritage reported that on May 28, 2026, the Mayor, Board President Mandelman and the organization announced a commitment to streamline landmarking. SF Heritage said 65 properties had been brought forward for consideration in 2026. That is an advocacy group's account. If new designations follow, more buildings could get the protections that contributors have now.
FAQ
Does Article 10 regulate interior renovations? Planning says residential interiors generally are not regulated by Article 10. Ordinary maintenance and in-kind repair do not require a COA.
Do district homes use the Mills Act? Some do. In December 2022, the Board of Supervisors approved a Mills Act historical property contract for 942–944 Fell Street. Eligibility and terms depend on the property and should be reviewed with qualified advisors.
What does the district protect architecturally? Appendix E cites residential architecture from the 1870s to the 1920s, with small scale, wood construction, heavy ornamentation, and hillside basements and retaining walls.
If you own a home in the Alamo Square district or are considering buying one, Domain SF Marin can review the building's historic rating and the ratings of the surrounding lots before you set a price or write an offer. Let's Meet — Request a personalized home valuation.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.